It was a dark day in Oilers Nation. The Oilers had traded Ryan Smyth to the New York Islanders for 2 prospects and a 1st round draft pick. At the time the Oilers had been in the middle of the basement and 9th place.
According to many sources, it was a difference of $100K-$200K. But for Lowe, it seemed like the right move to make.
Over a year and a half after this deal was made, what do Oilers fans think? Smyth played 20 games for the Islanders, lead them to 8th place in the East and an exit of the first round of the playoffs. Giving the Oilers the 15th overall draft choice in the draft. Robert Nilsson played a few games in the minors having great chemistry with another Oilers top prospect, Rob Schremp. But it was Nilsson that got the call-up, not Schremp. And in those games Nilsson wow'd a few Oiler fans. In the draft, the Oilers chose Alex Plante with that pick. With big names like Alex Cherepanov and Angelo Esposito still on the board, it may have upsetted some Oilers fans.
The following season, the trade didn't look good at all, at the beginning. Robert Nilsson had a slow start to the season going down to the minors for a few games. Later getting called up. Ryan O'Marra, the 2-time World Jr. gold medalist got sent down from the AHL down to the ECHL. But he later came back to the Falcons in the AHL. During the later part of the season, Nilsson showed what he could do and wow'd Oilers fans once again. O'Marra wow'd some Springfield fans as well as the coaching staff later on in the season. But, Plante had an offseason, injuring himself, losing his powerplay time, losing some even strength time.
Now, how does the trade look? Excellent. It seemed like a bad deal at the time, but Lowe was patient and showed us how badly we ripped off the Islanders. O'Marra is still yet to set foot in the NHL, but he looks like a promising young prospect and possibly challenging for a spot on the roster as soon as this season. Plante has recently requested a trade from his junior club, likely giving him more powerplay time on another team. But by the way, Nilsson played at the end of last season, Nilsson for Smyth, straight up would look like a good deal. The only part of this deal I question, is Plante. And that's not exactly Lowe's fault, after all, he's not really in charge of scouting.
Showing posts with label nilsson. Show all posts
Showing posts with label nilsson. Show all posts
15.9.08
12.9.08
Expectations for 2008-2009: Forwards
I'm being EXTREMELY optimistic for the coming season in case you haven't been able to tell already.
Ales Hemsky-can he break out and become a superstar? My answer, yes. I like him a lot though.
Projected numbers: 75 GP, 25G, 65A, 90 points
Shawn Horcoff-he has to prove last year wasn't a fluke. Just signed a big deal. Will he live up to the hype?
Projected numbers: 80 GP, 40G, 45A, 85 points
Dustin Penner-will he be on the 1st line or not? The MacBlender is likely to come out, he will see some time on the 1st line. But he strikes best on the powerplay where he should get 1st powerplay minutes.
Projected numbers: 80 GP, 30G, 30A, 60 points
Erik Cole-one of the premier power forwards in the NHL. Where does he fit in? He will be in the top six through out the year. Expect big things in his contract year.
Projected numbers: 65 GP, 30G, 40A, 70 points
Sam Gagner-had a sensational rookie campaign. He has to shake off a sophmore slump but will likely get first powerplay minutes. He could also get an upgrade in linemates but will the chemistry of the kid line be ruined? I think he has another great season this year.
Projected numbers: 80 GP, 15G, 45A, 60 points
Robert Nilsson-he was a main part of the Ryan Smyth deal. The shoes were big to fill and he had a little bit of a rollercoaster ride last season. Was in MacT's dog house for the first half of the year but hit his stride with Gagner and Cogliano. He has a new contract, let's see if he can exceed the expectations of that contract.
Projected numbers: 78 GP, 18G, 40A, 58 points
Andrew Cogliano-the comparisons to Todd Marchant are not very accurate in my opinion. As a 20-year-old rookie Cogliano scored 18 goals including 3 game-winners in OT. He will definately develop into at least a 20-goal scorer with great wheels and can occasionally kill a penalty or two.
Projected numbers: 80 GP, 22G, 35A, 57 points
Ethan Moreau-everyone says how last year we wouldve been better with Souray and Horcoff. They're both great players but they never really remember Moreau. Moreau has missed so much time in the past two seasons it's almost as if the team doesn't need him. But when Moreau is in the lineup he definately brings something to the table. He's a great penalty killer and can pitch in a goal every now and then. I hope to see a full season out of him but I'll be happy with 65 games.
Projected numbers: 65 GP, 12G, 18A, 30 points
Fernando Pisani-his contract looked bad when it was first signed. A 3rd-liner who had one good playoff run. The fact of the matter is, is that he scored 18 goals that season. A 20-goal scorer is worth a lot to a team, especially if he can kill penalties. He is one of the most underrated players and I want to see big things.
Projected numbers: 78 GP, 17G, 25A, 32 points
Kyle Brodziak-had a great season last year. He had great chemistry with Stortini and Glencross but Glencross is no longer here. He scored 14 goals and hit about 12 posts. I can see him being a 20-goal scorer in the future as well as a solid penalty killer.
Projected numbers: 82 GP, 18G, 25A, 33 points
Zack Stortini-"Huggy Bear" isn't exactly the most skilled player in the league, or the best fighter. But he somehow manages to impress the Oilers coaches with his work ethic. He definately needs to work on his stickhandling, shooting and speed (the 3 s'). But he can lay out the body and provide a spark when needed. With the addition of Strudwick he might get a birds eye view of the game more often than last year.
Projected numbers: 65 GP, 1G, 2A, 3 points
Who does the last roster spot go to?
Marc Pouliot-during the tail end of last season Pouliot showed a little bit of his 1st round form. Deemed a bust by a lot of Oilers fans, Pouliot is slowly moving his way up the Oilers depth chart and could see himself as the 3rd line center on opening night. I have never been too high on Pouliot but I believe he is a legitimate NHL player and his upside could be as high as a 2nd-3rd line center (depending on the team).
Projected numbers: 65 GP, 10G, 15A, 25 points
Ryan Potulny-I don't believe he will clear waivers and he has proven he can play at an NHL level. It gives me reason to believe he will be the 13th forward at the end of camp. The Oilers gave up 2nd-3rd pairing AHL dman Danny Syvret for him, so if he's the 13th forward it'll show to be a great deal for the Oilers.
Projected numbers: 25 GP, 6G, 8A, 14 points
Too lazy to italicize and bold.
Ales Hemsky-can he break out and become a superstar? My answer, yes. I like him a lot though.
Projected numbers: 75 GP, 25G, 65A, 90 points
Shawn Horcoff-he has to prove last year wasn't a fluke. Just signed a big deal. Will he live up to the hype?
Projected numbers: 80 GP, 40G, 45A, 85 points
Dustin Penner-will he be on the 1st line or not? The MacBlender is likely to come out, he will see some time on the 1st line. But he strikes best on the powerplay where he should get 1st powerplay minutes.
Projected numbers: 80 GP, 30G, 30A, 60 points
Erik Cole-one of the premier power forwards in the NHL. Where does he fit in? He will be in the top six through out the year. Expect big things in his contract year.
Projected numbers: 65 GP, 30G, 40A, 70 points
Sam Gagner-had a sensational rookie campaign. He has to shake off a sophmore slump but will likely get first powerplay minutes. He could also get an upgrade in linemates but will the chemistry of the kid line be ruined? I think he has another great season this year.
Projected numbers: 80 GP, 15G, 45A, 60 points
Robert Nilsson-he was a main part of the Ryan Smyth deal. The shoes were big to fill and he had a little bit of a rollercoaster ride last season. Was in MacT's dog house for the first half of the year but hit his stride with Gagner and Cogliano. He has a new contract, let's see if he can exceed the expectations of that contract.
Projected numbers: 78 GP, 18G, 40A, 58 points
Andrew Cogliano-the comparisons to Todd Marchant are not very accurate in my opinion. As a 20-year-old rookie Cogliano scored 18 goals including 3 game-winners in OT. He will definately develop into at least a 20-goal scorer with great wheels and can occasionally kill a penalty or two.
Projected numbers: 80 GP, 22G, 35A, 57 points
Ethan Moreau-everyone says how last year we wouldve been better with Souray and Horcoff. They're both great players but they never really remember Moreau. Moreau has missed so much time in the past two seasons it's almost as if the team doesn't need him. But when Moreau is in the lineup he definately brings something to the table. He's a great penalty killer and can pitch in a goal every now and then. I hope to see a full season out of him but I'll be happy with 65 games.
Projected numbers: 65 GP, 12G, 18A, 30 points
Fernando Pisani-his contract looked bad when it was first signed. A 3rd-liner who had one good playoff run. The fact of the matter is, is that he scored 18 goals that season. A 20-goal scorer is worth a lot to a team, especially if he can kill penalties. He is one of the most underrated players and I want to see big things.
Projected numbers: 78 GP, 17G, 25A, 32 points
Kyle Brodziak-had a great season last year. He had great chemistry with Stortini and Glencross but Glencross is no longer here. He scored 14 goals and hit about 12 posts. I can see him being a 20-goal scorer in the future as well as a solid penalty killer.
Projected numbers: 82 GP, 18G, 25A, 33 points
Zack Stortini-"Huggy Bear" isn't exactly the most skilled player in the league, or the best fighter. But he somehow manages to impress the Oilers coaches with his work ethic. He definately needs to work on his stickhandling, shooting and speed (the 3 s'). But he can lay out the body and provide a spark when needed. With the addition of Strudwick he might get a birds eye view of the game more often than last year.
Projected numbers: 65 GP, 1G, 2A, 3 points
Who does the last roster spot go to?
Marc Pouliot-during the tail end of last season Pouliot showed a little bit of his 1st round form. Deemed a bust by a lot of Oilers fans, Pouliot is slowly moving his way up the Oilers depth chart and could see himself as the 3rd line center on opening night. I have never been too high on Pouliot but I believe he is a legitimate NHL player and his upside could be as high as a 2nd-3rd line center (depending on the team).
Projected numbers: 65 GP, 10G, 15A, 25 points
Ryan Potulny-I don't believe he will clear waivers and he has proven he can play at an NHL level. It gives me reason to believe he will be the 13th forward at the end of camp. The Oilers gave up 2nd-3rd pairing AHL dman Danny Syvret for him, so if he's the 13th forward it'll show to be a great deal for the Oilers.
Projected numbers: 25 GP, 6G, 8A, 14 points
Too lazy to italicize and bold.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)